Lead acid batteries resist charge as they fill, which gives an alternator an easy life. Lithium does not. It accepts everything the alternator can make, for hours. A standard alternator at full output in a hot engine room will overheat.
The two risks
- Heat. Sustained full output burns out the windings or diodes.
- Sudden disconnect. If the BMS cuts the bank off while charging, the alternator has nowhere to send its output and the voltage spike can destroy its diodes and anything else connected.
Option 1: DC to DC charger
The alternator charges the lead acid start battery as it always did. A DC to DC charger then feeds the lithium bank at a fixed, limited current.
- Simple, and it solves both risks at once.
- Charge rate is limited to the charger size, commonly 30 to 60 amps.
- The right choice for most boats with a standard alternator.
Option 2: external regulator
An external regulator controls the alternator directly, with a temperature sensor bolted to its case. It backs the output off as the alternator heats up.
- Uses the full alternator output, so charging is faster.
- Needs an alternator that can be externally regulated, or a conversion.
- Still needs disconnect protection: a BMS that tells the regulator to stop first, or a protection device across the alternator.
Option 3: a bigger alternator
A high output alternator with external regulation and a serpentine belt suits boats that motor to charge. It costs the most and loads the engine's front end, so check the belt and the mounts.
How to test the result
- Run the engine at cruising revs with the bank at about half charge.
- After 20 minutes, measure the alternator case temperature with an infrared thermometer. Under about 100°C is the usual target; check the maker's limit.
- Watch the charge current on the battery monitor. It should be steady, at the figure you designed for.
- Ask the installer to show you what happens when the BMS disconnects.
Mistakes to avoid
- Charging lithium straight off a standard alternator because it worked on the first day.
- Fitting a DC to DC charger bigger than half the alternator's rating.
The usual arrangement
Which option suits which boat
| Boat | Sensible choice |
|---|---|
| Small bank, standard alternator, mostly solar | DC to DC charger |
| Large bank, lots of motoring, want fast charging | External regulator with temperature sensing |
| Old small frame alternator near the end of its life | New higher output alternator with an external regulator |
| Charter or shared boat | DC to DC charger, because nobody can set it wrong |
What you need on hand
- Clamp meter that reads DC amps
- Infrared thermometer or the temperature sensor that comes with the regulator
- The alternator model and its rated output
- Cable sized for the full charge current, with a fuse at the battery end
- The battery maker recommended charge voltage and maximum charge current
How hot is too hot
Most alternators are built to run hot, but not at full output for an hour. As a rough guide, a case temperature that keeps climbing past about 100 degrees C under charge means the alternator is being worked harder than it was designed for. Check the figure for your alternator. If the regulator has a temperature sensor, it will back the output off before that point, which is the reason to fit one.
What if the battery shuts itself off
A lithium battery can disconnect without warning if a cell goes out of range. If that happens while the alternator is charging hard, the voltage spike can destroy the alternator diodes. Three things protect you: a lead acid start battery left in the charge path, a battery that warns the regulator before it disconnects, or an alternator protection device across the output. Use at least one. Two is better.
